Powered by: Motilal Oswal
2026-11-22 02:43:05 pm | Source: Julius Baer
Quote on Gold and silver: Do not catch a falling knife By Carsten Menke, Head of Next Generation Research, Julius Baer
Quote on Gold and silver: Do not catch a falling knife By Carsten Menke, Head of Next Generation Research, Julius Baer

Below the Quote on Gold and silver: Do not catch a falling knife By Carsten Menke, Head of Next Generation Research, Julius Baer

 

The dominance of flows in the gold and silver markets continues. It almost looks like a mirror image of the early-year frenzy. Excessive expectations of US monetary policy tightening are now driving prices lower. The fundamental backdrop has deteriorated, but probably not as much as prices suggest. Still, the most important rule in such flow-driven markets is not to catch a falling knife, be it golden or silver. We want to see signs of a bottoming process first, and we maintain our views: Neutral on silver and Constructive on gold.

It very much looks like the mirror image from the beginning of this year. Excessive expectations of US monetary policy tightening are driving the price performance in the gold and silver markets. Prices are down 8.5% and 13.5% this week, respectively. Flows are dominating the markets, while the fundamental backdrop has undoubtedly deteriorated. Is it as bad as prices suggest? Probably not, but based on the price performance, it almost feels as if one of our bearish wild cards for this year, the return of US exceptionalism and the dominance of the US dollar, is materialising. While the US economy remains very resilient, we would refrain from calling this exceptionalism, and we believe that the US dollar is still set to weaken in the longer term. Yet, today’s market environment looks like the mirror image of the debasement trade that fuelled the speculative frenzy at the beginning of the year. How long this will last is impossible to tell. The early-year frenzy lasted around two months. The potential trigger to end the price pressure is easier to identify – a change in US monetary policy expectations. We still stick to our assessment that easing energy price pressure should allow the US Federal Reserve to be less aggressive next year. The most important rule in such flow-driven markets is not to catch a falling knife, no matter if it is golden or silver. In flow-driven markets, fundamental signposts disappear. This is particularly the case for the precious metals, since many investors are active in the physical market. The decision to buy or sell triggers a flow which, when happening at scale, changes the fundamental backdrop. Buying from investors tightens the physical market balance; selling eases it. As such, the selling of physically backed gold and silver products remains the biggest risk. Holdings have hardly budged, but disappointed investors might eventually decide to part with their positions. While we stand by our statement that a buying opportunity could open up in silver if prices drop below USD 45 and if the gold/silver ratio rises above 85 – levels where we are today – we are awaiting signs of a bottom-building process. Until then, we stick to our established views: Neutral on silver and Constructive on gold. That said, the view on gold is focused much more on the long-term outlook of a weakening US dollar, returning concerns about US indebtedness, and ongoing central bank gold buying. While these factors may have faded from the market’s focus at the moment, they have not disappeared as fundamental drivers.

 

Above views are of the author and not of the website kindly read disclaimer

Disclaimer: The content of this article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial or investment advice. Investments in financial markets are subject to market risks, and past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers are strongly advised to consult a licensed financial expert or advisor for tailored advice before making any investment decisions. The data and information presented in this article may not be accurate, comprehensive, or up-to-date. Readers should not rely solely on the content of this article for any current or future financial references. To Read Complete Disclaimer Click Here